Tuesday, March 18, 2008

MP Shihab calls for boycott of elections

MP for Male’ Mohamed Shihab has called on opposition parties to boycott the forthcoming presidential elections if the proposed amendments to the Civil Service Act by the government are endorsed by the Majlis. He made the call speaking at the Majlis session held yesterday.

Speaking at the Majlis yesterday Mohamed Shihab said the proposed amendment by the government to the Civil Service Act does not reflect the principles of the constitution.

“If the proposed amendments are endorsed then the forthcoming elections cannot be either free or fair, these amendments are politically motivated” said Male’ MP Shihab.

Responding to opposition claims regarding the failure of the government to consult the Civil Service Commission, Legal Reform Minister Mohamed Nasheed said that in order to discuss the amendment of the Civil Service Act, Dr. Mohamed latheef President of the Civil Service Commission was contacted twice and that he failed to respond. He pointed out that the Bill was proposed by then State Minister Ahmed Nazim and supported by the then Home Minister.

“I did ask Dr. Latheef for a meeting to hold discussions on the subject several times but every time it was turned down, Dr. Latheef said that there was no need to discuss the Bill with him as he was there only to administer it once passed and that his views and opinion was not required to amend the Bill. Political thinking last year was to support the Bill and get the Majlis endorsement and to incorporate the amendments at the earliest” said Minister Nasheed.

Opposing the amendments MP for Thaa Atoll as well as President of the MDP Parliamentary Group Hassan Afeef said that he will not support the amendments and pointed out that it was politically motivated designed to keep a specific person in power.

Supporting the amendments President’s member Fathin Hameed said every amendment proposed protects specific rights of the people including several basic rights.

Thasmeen to be running mate of President Gayoom


Reliable sources confirm that Baa Atoll MP as well as one of the Vice Presidents of Dhivehi Rahyithunge Party (DRP) Ahmed Thasmeen Ali has been deiced by DRP to be the running mate of President Maumoon Abdul Gayoom in the forthcoming Presidential Elections.

According to sources 2 of the 3 Vice Presidents of DRP have keen interest to be the running mate of President Gayoom. Sources say that opinion is divided among party members as to who should be the running mate of President Gayoom. Some claim that current Atolls Minister Ahmed Thasmeen Ali would be best choice while other says that Finance Minister Qasim Ibrahim would be best.

Party members say that even though Minister Qasim is a Vice President many senior members do not accept him to be a member of the party. They say that this could be the main reason why President Gayoom chose Minister Thasmeen over Minister Qasim. According to information received to Miadhu Daily senior members and members of inner circle of President Gayoom are unanimous that Minister Thasmeen should be the running mate. Sources say that running mate will be decided on by the Party’s Congress and as such it not clear who is going to be running mate at his point in time. They say what is clear is that approval of the President’s inner circle would be required to be the running mate.

Speaking to Miadhu Daily a senior member of the party said that Minister Qasim and Minister Thasmeen have indicated their keenness for the position. He said that they are 2 very different personalities with contrasting views and policies. He said while Minster Qasim is person with tremendous popular support Minister Thasmeen is seen as person who does not have much ties with the people and politically immature.

Audio clip of Minister Qasim leaked to youtube.com

An audio clip believed to contain Finance Minister Qasim’s voice has been posted on internationally well known website known as www.you tube.com. The audio clip indicates that Finance Minister Qasim is not working for the government in the capacity of Finance Minister on his own free will but is forced to do so.

The audio clip indicates that Minister Qasim is not working for the government on own free will but is forced do so. It also indicates Minister Qasim do not trust President Gayoom.

In the audio clip, a voice believed to be of Minister Qasim says” a person who was kept behind bars yesterday, or a person who was sentenced to life, cannot accept it even if he is made to sit on a bed of roses”. It particularly pointed out such a thing cannot be accepted to Qasim Ibrahim.

“How can person who was kept behind bars yesterday or sentenced to life accept even if his made to sit on bed of roses, I cannot for sure accept it, I am in this position not because I accept it” said the voice believed to be of Finance Minister Qasim.

A while back another 2 audio clips were also posted on you tube. Many believe that such audio clips started appearing on websites following the sacking of reporter Hiriga Husham from a local daily believed to be connected to Finance Minister. Sources claim that it is possible that Hiriga Husham may possess such audios and that further clips can be expected. However some claim that audio clip may be electronically manipulated.

Despite Miadhu Daily’s attempts to contact Minister Qasim to obtain his comment it proved futile.

Majlis Battle On Civil Service Amendments

The much-criticised amendments to the Civil Service Act 2007 were on Monday debated in a belligerent session of the People’s Majlis (parliament), with opposition politicians arguing the proposals are a “politically motivated” attempt to retain presidential control over a large and influential section of Maldives’ public servants.

The government proposes groups including the police, elections commission staff, island chiefs and the anti-corruption board should remain under the ambit of the President’s Office pending new legislation to deal with them separately.

But opposition parliamentarians estimate that if the amendments pass a parliamentary vote, President Maumoon Abdul Gayoom could retain direct power over twelve to fifteen thousand of the Maldives’ 40,000 government employees in the run-up to the country’s first multi-party elections.

Exceptions

Information minister Mohamed Nasheed has proposed a series of amendments to the Civil Service Act which would reduce the number of employees falling under the independent Civil Service Commission (CSC) by around a third.

The CSC said it was not consulted about the amendments, and the relevant sectors have already been temporarily excluded following a presidential order earlier this month.

The Act, due to come into full force in May, makes the civil service – proportionally one of the world’s largest – independent under the CSC, which came into being late last year.

A central pledge of the government’s Roadmap to the Reform Agenda, the Act was proposed as a private member’s bill and passed in May 2007.

The bill passed a Majlis vote, after an eighteen-month parliamentary process, at a time when the Maldives found itself under intense international scrutiny after protests and mass jailings following the suspected custodial death of Hussein Solah.

Necessary

Legal reform commissioner Mohamed Anil argues the amendments are necessary because they cover “any institution excluded by another [proposed] law”. Under the constitution in progress, bodies such as the police, army and anti-corruption board must be overseen by independent commissions.

But opposition politicians are sceptical, arguing the backlog of bills awaiting Majlis consideration means the government cannot guarantee any timeframe for the laws creating new commissions, so the CSC should take over in the interim.

“The moment [these amendments are] passed, the control of all these positions reverts back to the president because there is no one else – there are no commissions,” says Ibrahim Ismail MP, of the fledgling Social Liberal Party (SLP). “The government has no intention of implementing any of these.”

Retirement

The proposals also include a two-year delay before compulsory retirement for 65 year olds, to allow retirees to “mentally or physically prepare”, according to head of the ruling Dhivehi Raiyyithunge Party (DRP) parliamentary group Aneesa Ahmed.

Under the proposals, “people who worked for the government for a prolonged period and are honorary members of the government” would also remain under the president’s office.

Both amendments raise the contentious issue of “beached” civil servants, who remain on the government payroll despite no longer attending work.

No reliable figures are available for the number of such civil servants, but the opposition contend the phenomenon occurs frequently, allowing the government to ensure support from respected figures in local communities.

Ahmed Nazim, an MP and member of the People’s Association political group, said that even of the 1,700 due to retire under the Civil Service Act, “the majority are retirees already”.

The CSC had previously announced it would use from May its power to compel civil servants over 65 to retire on a government pension.

Island Chiefs

With the Maldives’ first ever multi-party elections due later this year, the opposition Maldivian Democratic Party (MDP) has argued the President’s power to appoint atoll and island chiefs and their assistants – a total of 473 individuals – is a threat to electoral fairness.

The amendments would see the chiefs continuing to report to the President’s office until local elections, which the DRP propose should take place after presidential and parliamentary polls.

High-ranking civil servants including “staff at the level of ministers”, state ministers, special advisors, and ministers’ assistants, would remain under the President’s office permanently, a situation the CSC has said could cause “difficulties with lines of authority”.

The DRP are confident of passing the amendments, according to Aneesa. But even with their majority, which includes eight presidential appointees, chances of the bill passing are “50/50” according to Ibra, and head of the MDP parliamentary group Hassan Afeef says he believes the bill may yet be blocked.

International Election “Watchdog” Set Up By Former Foreign Minister

An international network of politicians and other professionals has been set up by former foreign minister Dr Ahmed Shaheed to help ensure the country’s first multi-party presidential elections are free and fair.


At least ten designated individuals, including British and European parliamentarians, will liaise with representatives in the Maldivian capital, Malé, to gain information on reform progress as elections approach.

Meanwhile, a pledged independent elections commission has not yet been created and the European Union is due to send just two to five “technical experts” to observe the polls.

Watchdog

Shaheed says the network, to be known as Maldives Election Watch, will oversee “anything that will affect the election process”.

Presidential elections are due to take place this year, although the date is dependent on the last chapter of the constitution in progress.

The new group will see key politicians and other professionals such as journalists gather information on progress in the run-up to elections, and then lobby national and regional governments to take up the issue.

Member of the European Parliament (MEP) Robert Evans is to act as chairperson of the group, which will also include British House of Lords Member George Foukes and Member of Parliament Andrew MacKinley, according to Shaheed.

Shaheed argues the Maldivian government has failed to act on a number of pledges aimed to make elections free and fair, including full media independence, an end to government appointment of atoll and island chiefs, and an independent elections commission.

Reforms

The move by Shaheed, who is also part of the New Maldives political group along with presidential contender Hassan Saeed, comes at a time when international pressure is mounting on the government to pass reforms to ensure a free and fair election.

In particular, an independent elections commission was pledged to replace the existing body, which is headed by presidential appointee Ahmed KD Manik.

Government officials including legal reform commissioner Mohamed Anil now argue such independent commissions cannot be put in place until the constitution in progress is complete, giving a them a legal mandate.

But for Shaheed, “there is no argument for not creating these [independent bodies] now”.

He added that proposed amendments to the Civil Service Act will also “undermine the neutrality of the civil service”, and in turn unfairly influence the elections.

The amendments, currently being debated in parliament, include provisions for atoll and island chiefs to remain under the president’s jurisdiction.

Shaheed argues that despite promises of reform, “the people that really matter [in terms of influencing the elections] are still in place”.

International Monitoring

The European Union will send an “expert team” to observe the elections, but will not be carrying out full observation or monitoring.

Rosham Lyman, Head of Politics and Trade at the EU delegation to Colombo, told Minivan News two to five “fully-fledged technical experts” would be sent.

Previous elections have been surrounded by allegations of corruption, and on a visit in February, Conservative MP Francis Maude said: “I don’t think anyone would seriously pretend that there have been free and fair elections in the past.”

The August 2007 referendum, which resulted in the adoption of a presidential rather than a parliamentary system of government, was judged by the Human Rights Commission to be “generally fair”. But the elections commission has since admitted serious flaws in voter lists and authentication.

The right to free and fair elections is enshrined in the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR), to which the Maldives acceded in September 2006.